Kitchen · Buying Guide
Best Roasting Pan (2026): 8 Picks for Thanksgiving Turkey, Chicken and Veggies
Hosting Thanksgiving? These 8 roasting pans cover tri-ply stainless, nonstick, V-racks, small pans and a covered roaster, plus what size pan fits your turkey and whether you need a rack.

This guide is research-based; products were not tested hands-on.
One week out from Thanksgiving, the turkey is ordered, the guest count keeps changing, and you are not trusting that flimsy foil pan again. You know the one: it buckles the second you lift a hot bird and sends drippings down the oven door. This is your shortcut to the best roasting pan for your kitchen: one that fits your turkey and your oven, catches drippings you can turn into gravy, and earns its cabinet space with roast chicken, trays of vegetables, ham and lasagna all year. These are researched recommendations, not hands-on test results.
As an Amazon Associate, ReviewDeal earns from qualifying purchases.
Below are eight picks: a best overall tri-ply stainless roaster, a best value stainless option, a best nonstick for a big turkey, a best V-rack roaster, a best splurge hybrid, a best budget everyday roaster, a best small pan and a best covered roaster. Before the reviews, there's a turkey sizing guide so you can match the pan to the bird and a comparison table for quick scanning. After them come plain-English advice on choosing (rack, lid, stainless or nonstick), a stress-free roasting plan and an FAQ with the questions people ask most this time of year.

Quick Picks: The Best Roasting Pan for Every Kitchen
Best overall: Cuisinart MultiClad Pro 16" Stainless Roasting Pan & Rack: tri-ply stainless "to the rim," a listing-stated capacity of turkeys up to 18 pounds, and it can go straight onto the stovetop (induction included) for gravy.
Best value stainless: Cuisinart Chef's Classic Stainless 16" Roasting Pan with Rack: a 16-inch stainless roaster with a rack and an aluminum-encapsulated base, oven safe to 500°F and lighter than the MultiClad Pro.
Best nonstick for a big turkey: Circulon Total Bakeware Nonstick Roaster with U-Rack, 17 x 13 Inch: Circulon says it holds up to a 24-pound turkey, yet the pan is listed at just 3.2 pounds.
Best V-rack roaster: Cooks Standard Classic 14 x 12 Inch Stainless Steel Roaster with V-Shaped Rack: an 18/10 stainless pan with a V-rack that cradles a smaller bird and leaves room for vegetables underneath.
Best splurge (hybrid nonstick): HexClad Hybrid Roasting Pan with Rack, 17 x 14 Inch: tri-ply construction with HexClad's stainless-and-ceramic hybrid surface, and the listing says it works on any cooktop, including induction.
Best budget everyday roaster: Farberware Bakeware Nonstick Roaster with Flat Rack, 11 x 15 Inch: a light, shallow nonstick roaster with a flat rack, built for weeknight chicken, pork loin and vegetables.
Best small roasting pan: Chicago Metallic Roasting Pan with Rack, 13.5 x 9.5 Inch: a compact nonstick pan with a rack, sized for a single chicken or a Thanksgiving side, with a 25-year limited warranty per the listing.
Best covered roaster: Granite Ware 13" Oval Roaster with Lid: the classic speckled enamel roaster that weighs 1.5 pounds and fits up to a 7-pound bird or roast, per the listing.
What Size Roasting Pan Do You Need for Your Turkey?
If you've ever stood in a store aisle wondering what size roasting pan for turkey day you actually need, you're not alone. Cooking guides broadly share a rough rule of thumb. A pan around 14 inches long suits birds up to about 12 pounds. A pan around 16 inches suits birds up to about 16 pounds. An 18-inch-class pan suits birds up to about 20 pounds.
Treat that as a starting point, not a guarantee. You want an inch or two of open space around the bird so hot air can circulate. Many cooks like sides about 3 inches high, which is deep enough to catch drippings and shallow enough that the lower part of the bird roasts instead of steaming. Always check the maker's stated capacity when there is one.
Turkey or roast | Pan size to look for | Picks that fit (per the listings) |
|---|---|---|
Whole chicken, small roast or vegetables (up to about 7 lb) | About 13 inches, or a small oval covered roaster | Granite Ware 13" Oval (listing: up to 7 lb); Chicago Metallic 13.5 x 9.5 (listed capacity 5 lb); Farberware 11 x 15 (by pan size; no capacity listed) |
Turkey breast or small turkey (up to about 12 lb) | Roughly 14 inches | Cooks Standard 14 x 12 (roughly, based on its 14 x 11-inch interior); Farberware 11 x 15 for a turkey breast (shallow, so check the listing) |
Medium turkey (about 12–16 lb) | Roughly 16 inches | Cuisinart MultiClad Pro (listing: up to 18 lb); Circulon (brand: up to 24 lb); Cuisinart Chef's Classic and HexClad (roughly, based on 16-inch-class size; no capacity listed); Cooks Standard only at the low end, roughly 14 lb |
Large turkey (about 16–18 lb) | 16 to 18 inches, with deeper sides | Cuisinart MultiClad Pro (listing: up to 18 lb); Circulon (brand: up to 24 lb); Chef's Classic and HexClad: check the listing, since a 16-inch class pan is near its rough limit here |
Very large turkey (about 18–24 lb) | 18-inch class or larger | Circulon (Circulon's page says up to 24 lb); none of the other picks list a capacity this large |
Now grab a tape measure and check your oven, which is the step everyone skips. Measure the interior width of your oven, wall to wall, and compare it with the pan's overall length including handles, not just the cooking surface. Leave a couple of inches between the pan and the oven walls so heat can move. For reference, the Cuisinart Chef's Classic is listed at 20.7 inches long, the Cuisinart MultiClad Pro at 19.3 inches overall, and the HexClad at up to 18.75 inches overall per HexClad. If your oven is on the narrow side, those numbers matter.
Do You Need a Roasting Pan? (And What to Use Instead)
Honest answer: it depends on how often you roast. If a turkey, a big chicken, a ham or a crowded tray of root vegetables shows up on your table more than once a year, a real roasting pan pays you back. It's sturdy enough to lift with a heavy bird inside, tall enough to hold drippings without sloshing, and often comes with a rack that lifts the meat so the bottom browns.
If you mostly cook a small chicken or a pan of vegetables, you probably already own something that works. A rimmed sheet pan handles vegetables and a spatchcocked chicken nicely. A large baking dish is fine for a small chicken or a ham. A Dutch oven can manage a small roast. For a single chicken or smaller roast, a cast iron skillet gives you great browning and can go on the stove afterward for a quick pan sauce. The catch is that none of these is ideal for a 14-pound-plus turkey. They're too shallow, too small or too awkward to lift.
A real roasting pan makes sense if you're roasting a whole turkey, you host holidays regularly, you want stovetop gravy straight from the drippings, or you roast large cuts and big vegetable batches through the colder months.
A real roasting pan makes sense if you're tired of disposable pans and want one sturdy pan with real handles that you can lift with confidence.
You can skip one if you cook for one or two, rarely roast anything bigger than a chicken, and already have a rimmed sheet pan, a big baking dish or a skillet you love.
You can skip one if you're helping rather than hosting and someone else's oven (and pan) is handling the turkey this year.
How We Chose
ReviewDeal did not hands-on test these pans. This guide is built on research. We started with verified Amazon listings and confirmed current availability on November 18, 2026. We skipped one listing that would not load and another that did not show clear availability. Where the brand publishes its own specs, we cross-checked the manufacturer pages, specifically HexClad's and Circulon's product pages. Where the sources disagree, we tell you so.
We aimed for a real spread of materials and sizes: tri-ply stainless, encapsulated-base stainless, nonstick steel, a stainless-and-ceramic hybrid and porcelain enamel. Then we weighed what matters when you're pulling a hot pan out of the oven: rack type, handle design, listed weight, maximum oven temperature, whether the pan can go on the stovetop (and induction) for gravy, warranty terms, and the trade-offs cooking guides broadly agree on. Prices shift constantly, so we describe each pick as budget-friendly, mid-range or splurge rather than quoting figures.
Roasting Pans Compared
Model | Material | Size (as listed) | Rack | Max oven temp | Best for | Shop |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Cuisinart MultiClad Pro 16" | Tri-ply stainless (aluminum core) | 16 in class; 19.3 x 12.1 x 5.2 in overall | Stainless rack | 500°F | Best overall; holds turkeys up to 18 lb (listing) | |
Cuisinart Chef's Classic 16" | Stainless, aluminum-encapsulated base | 16 in class; 20.7 x 12 x 4.9 in | Stainless rack | 500°F, broiler-ready | Best value stainless | |
Circulon 17 x 13 | Nonstick steel | 16 x 12.3 x 5.3 in (brand) vs 17 x 13 x 3.8 in (listing) | Chrome U-rack | 450°F | Big turkeys, up to 24 lb (brand) | |
Cooks Standard 14 x 12 | 18/10 stainless | Interior 14 x 11 x 3 in; 15 x 12 in overall | Stainless V-rack | 500°F | V-rack roasting for smaller birds; not induction | |
HexClad 17 x 14 | Hybrid stainless + ceramic nonstick, tri-ply | About 16.5–18.75 x 14–14.57 x 3.35–3.5 in (sources vary) | Rack included | 900°F (bullets, brand) vs 450°F (one listing field) | Splurge; nonstick with induction gravy | |
Farberware 11 x 15 | Nonstick steel | 16 x 11.25 x 2.25 in | Chrome flat rack | 450°F | Budget everyday roasting | |
Chicago Metallic 13.5 x 9.5 | Nonstick carbon steel | 13.5 x 9.5 x 2.25 in | Nonstick flat rack | 450°F | Small households; capacity 5 lb (listing) | |
Granite Ware 13" Oval | Porcelain enamel on steel, with lid | 13 x 8.1 x 5.3 in | No rack | 932°F (listing) | Covered roasting, up to 7 lb (listing) |
Our 8 Roasting Pan Picks, Reviewed
1. Cuisinart MultiClad Pro 16" Stainless Roasting Pan & Rack: Best Overall
Best for: Hosts who want one serious pan that handles a Thanksgiving turkey, goes on the stovetop for gravy, and lasts for years of roasts.
This is the pan to buy if you only want to buy once. It's tri-ply stainless all the way up the sides, so the aluminum core isn't just in the base. Cuisinart says its "Heat Surround technology" distributes heat evenly and helps eliminate hot spots. On paper, it checks every box: a listing-stated capacity of turkeys up to 18 pounds, a stainless rack, oven safety to 500°F, and induction compatibility so you can set it across two burners and whisk gravy right where the drippings landed.
One honest heads-up. Cuisinart's own website currently lists this roaster model (MCP117-16BR) on a "discontinued" product page, while Amazon showed it in stock on November 18, 2026. If you want it, buy sooner rather than later, because availability may change. Also, one field on the Amazon listing describes the finish as "non-stick." That's clearly an error. This is uncoated stainless.
Key features:
16-inch rectangular tri-ply roaster: a pure aluminum core bonded between a brushed stainless exterior and polished stainless interior, "to the rim" (per the listing)
"Heat Surround technology" for even heating and fewer hot spots (Cuisinart says)
Stainless steel rack lifts roasts off the pan floor
Holds turkeys up to 18 lb (listing highlight)
Induction compatible, plus gas, electric and glass-ceramic cooktops; oven safe up to 500°F
Riveted handles; the listing says they stay cool on the stovetop but to use mitts after oven use
Polished stainless cooking surface does not react with food (per the listing)
Dishwasher safe, though the listing recommends hand washing to keep the polish
Listed at 19.3 x 12.1 x 5.2 in overall, 9.1 liters, 10 pounds; limited lifetime warranty
Pros
Full tri-ply construction up the walls, not just in the base
Stovetop and induction ready for deglazing and gravy
Clear stated turkey capacity (up to 18 lb) takes the guesswork out
No coating to wear out over the years
Cons
The heaviest pick here at 10 pounds before you add a single potato
Listed as discontinued on Cuisinart's site, so stock may not last
Stainless needs a soak or a deglaze to clean up the browned bits
Who should skip it: Anyone who struggles to lift heavy cookware, or who regularly roasts birds over 18 pounds. It's also not for you if you'd rather not scrub stainless.
2. Cuisinart Chef's Classic Stainless 16" Roasting Pan with Rack: Best Value Stainless
Best for: Cooks who want stainless steel and stovetop gravy without the top-tier spend or the 10-pound heft.
Think of this as the MultiClad Pro's more approachable sibling. You still get a 16-inch mirror-finish stainless roaster, a removable stainless rack and induction compatibility. The difference is construction. This pan has an aluminum-encapsulated base, which the listing says helps with even heating. The aluminum is in the base, not the walls, so the sides are single-layer stainless. For a turkey roasting at a steady oven temperature, that's a reasonable trade, and it's 3 pounds lighter than pick 1.
The one thing to watch is length. At a listed 20.7 inches with handles, it's the longest pan on this list, so measure your oven before you click. There's also no stated turkey capacity on the listing, so go by the general 16-inch rule: roughly up to 16 pounds.
Key features:
16-inch mirror-finish stainless roaster with removable stainless rack
Aluminum-encapsulated base for even heating (per the listing)
Drip-free tapered rims for pouring off drippings
Uncoated stainless; induction compatible
Oven safe to 500°F and broiler-ready
Riveted stainless handles, which the listing says get hot in the oven (use mitts)
Dishwasher safe, though hand washing is recommended; the listing warns improper loading can mar the finish
Listed at 20.7 x 12 x 4.9 in and 7 pounds; lifetime warranty (per the listing)
Pros
Stainless and stovetop-ready (including induction) at a mid-range tier
Lighter than the full tri-ply pick
Tapered rims make pouring drippings into a gravy pot less messy
Broiler-ready, which is handy for browning a ham glaze
Cons
The longest pan here, so it may not fit narrower ovens
Aluminum is in the base only, so heat along the walls is less even than tri-ply
No stated turkey capacity on the listing
Who should skip it: Anyone with a narrow or compact oven, or anyone planning a turkey over about 16 pounds who wants a stated capacity to rely on.
3. Circulon Total Bakeware Nonstick Roaster with U-Rack, 17 x 13 Inch: Best Nonstick for a Big Turkey
Best for: Hosts with a big bird on order who want a light pan and easy cleanup.
If your turkey is pushing 20 pounds, this is the pick with the biggest stated capacity: Circulon's product page says it holds up to a 24-pound turkey, ham or roast. It's heavy-duty steel with a nonstick interior and a chrome-plated U-shaped rack that cradles the bird and keeps it off the pan floor. At a listed 3.2 pounds, it's about a third of the weight of the MultiClad Pro, which your wrists will appreciate.
Light is a mixed blessing, though. A thin, light steel pan holding a 20-plus-pound bird still needs two hands, sturdy mitts and a clear path to the counter. Sizing is also a little confusing. It's sold as 17 x 13 inches, but Circulon's page lists 16 x 12.3 inches and 5.3 inches tall with a 14.3 x 12-inch baking surface, while the Amazon listing gives 17 x 13 x 3.8 inches. When you measure your oven, go by the brand's 16 x 12.3-inch figure and 14.3 x 12-inch base.
Key features:
Heavy-duty steel nonstick roaster; Circulon describes "superior nonstick" and "fast, even heat" (brand claims)
Chrome-plated U-shaped rack keeps meat off the bottom
Wide handles
Oven safe to 450°F
Holds up to a 24 lb turkey, ham or roast (Circulon's page)
Dishwasher safe, hand wash recommended (brand page)
Listed weight 3.2 pounds; limited lifetime warranty (brand page)
Pros
Largest stated capacity on this list
Light enough to maneuver before the bird goes in
U-rack lifts the turkey for better air flow and doubles as lifting handles
Nonstick release makes cleanup faster
Cons
450°F max, so it's not for very high-heat roasting
No stovetop use stated: pour drippings into a saucepan to make gravy
Listed dimensions differ between the brand and Amazon; avoid abrasive scrubbers on the coating
Who should skip it: Anyone set on whisking gravy in the roasting pan itself, or anyone who prefers an uncoated pan that will never need replacing for wear.
4. Cooks Standard Classic 14 x 12 Inch Stainless Steel Roaster with V-Shaped Rack: Best V-Rack Roaster
Best for: Smaller gatherings, turkey breasts and birds up to roughly 12–14 pounds, plus Sunday chickens all year.
A V-rack is the classic turkey tool. It cradles the bird and lifts it higher than a flat rack, so heat reaches the underside and you get room for onions, carrots and aromatics beneath. This 18/10 stainless roaster pairs one with a pan that has 3-inch interior walls, right in the sweet spot cooking guides like for catching drippings without steaming the bird.
The interior is 14 x 11 inches, so by the general size rule this suits birds up to roughly 12 to 14 pounds, not a 20-pounder. It works on gas, electric, glass and ceramic cooktops, but the listing says it is not induction compatible. And since no aluminum core is stated, keep the heat moderate and keep stirring when you make gravy on the stove.
Key features:
18/10 heavy-gauge stainless steel with a flat bottom
V-shaped stainless rack that cradles a bird and leaves room for vegetables and aromatics
Interior 14 x 11 inches, 3 inches high; 15 x 12 inches edge to edge and 5.4 inches tall with handles
Riveted stainless handles; oven safe to 500°F
Works on gas, electric, glass and ceramic cooktops; not induction compatible (per the listing)
Dishwasher safe; listed capacity 4 quarts; listed weight 6.5 pounds
1-year hassle-free replacement warranty through Cook N Home (per the listing)
Pros
True V-rack for lift and browning
Compact enough for smaller ovens
Uncoated stainless that can go on most stovetops for gravy
Budget-friendly to mid-range for stainless with a V-rack
Cons
Too small for a large Thanksgiving turkey
Not induction compatible
Shorter warranty than the Cuisinart picks
Who should skip it: Induction cooktop owners who want stovetop gravy, and anyone feeding a crowd with a turkey over about 14 pounds.

5. HexClad Hybrid Roasting Pan with Rack, 17 x 14 Inch: Best Splurge (Hybrid Nonstick)
Best for: Someone who wants nonstick-style release and stovetop gravy in the same pan, and is happy to invest.
HexClad's design is a laser-etched hexagonal stainless surface with the brand's TerraBond ceramic nonstick sitting in the "valleys." HexClad says the coating is free of PTFE and PFAS ("forever chemicals"). Underneath, it's tri-ply with an aluminum core, and the listing says it works on any cooktop, including induction. That makes it the only nonstick-style pick here that the listing clears for the stovetop. Brown the turkey, set the pan across two burners, deglaze, whisk. HexClad also says it's metal-utensil-safe and dishwasher-safe.
The specs don't all agree, so here's the full picture. On oven safety, the listing bullets and HexClad's page say 900°F, while one technical field on the Amazon listing says 450°F. Follow the care card that comes in the box. On size, the listing bullet says about 16.5 inches long, 14 wide and 3.5 high. A technical field says 17 x 14.5 x 3.5 inches. HexClad's own page (where it's sold as the "Large Hybrid Roasting Pan with Rack, 14 x 16") lists 18.75 inches long overall, 14.57 wide, 3.35 deep and 6.8 pounds. There's no stated turkey capacity, so go by its roughly 16-inch class.
Key features:
Hybrid surface: hexagonal stainless with TerraBond ceramic nonstick (HexClad says)
Coating free of PTFE and PFAS (HexClad says)
Tri-ply construction with an aluminum core; works on any cooktop, including induction (per the listing)
Metal-utensil-safe and dishwasher-safe (HexClad says)
Rack included
Oven safe to 900°F per the bullets and HexClad, vs 450°F in one listing field
About 6.8 pounds per HexClad's page
Lifetime warranty against manufacturer defects when sold by HexClad Cookware; commercial or restaurant use is excluded, and HexClad's warranty excludes damage from misuse such as excessive heat
Pros
Easier release than plain stainless, plus stovetop gravy
Induction compatible
Lighter than the MultiClad Pro, per the brand's listed weight
Doubles nicely for roast chicken, vegetables and lasagna
Cons
Splurge pricing
Conflicting oven-temperature and size figures across sources; no stated turkey capacity
Warranty wording depends on the seller; gentle cleaning is still wise even though the brand says dishwasher safe
Who should skip it: Budget-minded shoppers, anyone with a bird over about 16 pounds, and anyone who wants exact, consistent specs before buying.
6. Farberware Bakeware Nonstick Roaster with Flat Rack, 11 x 15 Inch: Best Budget Everyday Roaster
Best for: Weeknight roast chicken, pork loin, a small turkey breast and big batches of vegetables.
Not every roasting pan has to be a holiday showpiece. This is the light, wallet-friendly pan you'll grab on a random Tuesday. It's heavy-duty steel that Farberware says is designed to resist warping, with a removable chrome-plated flat rack that lets fat drip away. The handles are wide, dual-riveted cast stainless steel, and the rack has wide handles too, which helps when you're lifting with mitts on.
It's shallow, though, at about 2.25 inches. That's great for crisp-edged vegetables (it's a strong contender for the best roasting pan for vegetables on a budget) but less ideal for a big turkey that throws off a lot of drippings. A flat rack also gives less lift than a V or U rack. Farberware says the nonstick interior is made without PFAS, PFOA, lead or cadmium.
Key features:
Heavy-duty steel designed to resist warping (the brand says)
Removable chrome-plated flat rack raises meat so fat drips away
Wide dual-riveted cast stainless steel handles on the pan; wide handles on the rack
Nonstick interior made without PFAS, PFOA, lead or cadmium (the brand says)
Oven safe to 450°F
Listed at 16 x 11.25 x 2.25 in (sold as 11 x 15), 3 pounds, 450 cubic inches
Pros
Budget-friendly and light
Easy-release nonstick for quick weeknight cleanup
Shallow sides help vegetables brown
Sturdy-looking riveted handles on both pan and rack
Cons
Shallow for a large, juicy turkey
Flat rack offers less lift for a whole bird
No stated turkey capacity or stovetop use
Who should skip it: Anyone roasting a full-size Thanksgiving turkey or planning to make gravy in the pan on the stove.
7. Chicago Metallic Roasting Pan with Rack, 13.5 x 9.5 Inch: Best Small Roasting Pan
Best for: A single chicken, a small household, sheet-pan-style vegetables, or a second pan for Thanksgiving sides.
If you cook for one or two, this may be the best roasting pan for chicken in a compact footprint. The listing says it fits standard home ovens and handles whole chickens, roasts and casseroles. It's small carbon steel (0.4 mm vessel gauge) with a flat rack that has fold-out handles, and the nonstick coating covers the inside, outside and the rack. On Thanksgiving, it's a handy sidekick for stuffing baked outside the bird or a tray of Brussels sprouts while the turkey hogs the big pan.
A small quirk: the listing gives an outer rim-to-rim size of 13.5 x 9.5 x 2.25 inches but an inner cooking surface of 12.75 x 9.875 inches. That inner width is larger than the outer width, so treat the dimensions as approximate. Listed capacity is 5 pounds, so this is not a turkey pan.
Key features:
Carbon steel, 0.4 mm vessel gauge
Flat rack with fold-out handles
Nonstick coating inside, outside and on the rack; PTFE- and PFOA-free (per the listing)
Dishwasher, oven and metal-utensil safe (per the listing); oven safe to 450°F
Listed capacity 5 pounds
25-year limited warranty (per the listing)
Pros
Compact size for small ovens and small households
Rack included, which is rare at this size
Budget-friendly with a long listed warranty
Cons
Too small for any turkey
Thin-gauge steel
Listed dimensions don't quite add up
Who should skip it: Anyone shopping specifically for a Thanksgiving turkey pan.
8. Granite Ware 13" Oval Roaster with Lid: Best Covered Roaster (Small Birds and Bread)
Best for: Covered roasting of a whole chicken, Cornish hens, a small pork or beef roast, or a loaf of bread.
You may have grown up with one of these speckled roasters, and there's a reason they've stuck around. It's porcelain enamel on a steel core, weighs a listed 1.5 pounds and comes with a tight-fitting lid the brand calls self-basting. The lid traps moisture, which suits a small pot roast or a tender chicken. Because it traps steam, it's also marketed as a bread cloche for baking sourdough.
Keep expectations right-sized. The listing says it fits up to a 7-pound bird or roast, so it won't hold a Thanksgiving turkey. Granite Ware does make larger roasters, but this guide covers this 13-inch model only. A covered roaster also gives softer skin, so take the lid off near the end if you want browning. Enamel can chip if it's banged or dropped, so handle it with a little care.
Key features:
Porcelain enamel on a steel core
13-inch oval with a tight-fitting lid, called self-basting by the brand
Fits up to a 7 lb poultry or roast (per the listing)
Oven safe up to 932°F (per the listing); dishwasher safe
PFOA- and PTFE-free (per the listing); the brand says it will not absorb flavors
Listed at 13 x 8.1 x 5.3 in and 1.5 pounds
No rack included; warranty not stated on the listing
Pros
The lightest pick here
Lid included, for moist covered roasting
Doubles as a bread cloche
Budget-friendly
Cons
Too small for a turkey
No rack, and enamel can chip with rough handling
Softer skin unless you uncover it near the end
Who should skip it: Anyone who needs to roast a full turkey or loves shatter-crisp skin without extra steps.
Roasting Pan Buying Guide: What Actually Matters
Stainless, nonstick, enamel or hybrid?
Tri-ply or clad stainless heats evenly, can go on the stovetop for gravy, and has no coating to wear out. A good stainless steel roasting pan can last decades. The trade-off is cleanup: plan on a soak or a quick deglaze. Stainless with an encapsulated base puts the aluminum in the bottom only, which keeps the price friendlier.
Nonstick carbon or alloy steel is light, releases easily and cleans up fast. On these picks the max oven temperature is 450°F, the coating can wear over years, and it's usually not great for stovetop gravy over high heat. Porcelain enamel on steel is the classic speckled covered roaster: light, with a lid that traps moisture, and small sizes suit chickens and small roasts. Hybrid stainless and ceramic, HexClad's design, aims to give you both release and stovetop use. Copper and enameled cast iron exist too, but they're heavy or costly, so they aren't picks here.
Rack or no rack (flat, U-shaped, V-shaped)
A flat rack lifts a roast or chicken off the pan floor so fat drips away. A U-shaped or V-shaped rack cradles a turkey and lifts it higher, so the bottom browns, air moves underneath, and you get built-in handles for lifting the bird out. A rack also frees up space for vegetables and aromatics below and around the bird. If you want the best roasting pan with rack for a turkey, look for a U or V shape. No rack? A bed of thick-cut onions, carrots and celery works in a pinch and flavors the drippings.
Depth, handles and weight
Sides around 3 inches high are the sweet spot for most cooks: deep enough for drippings, shallow enough for browning. Very shallow pans (about 2.25 inches) are better for chicken and vegetables. Handles matter more than you think. Upright, riveted handles give you something solid to grip with thick mitts.
Weight cuts both ways. Listed pan weights here range from about 1.5 pounds to about 10 pounds. A 16-inch tri-ply pan plus a 16-pound turkey adds up to a real lift, so be honest with yourself about what you're comfortable carrying from a hot oven. If that's a concern, a lighter nonstick pan with a sturdy rack may serve you better.
Lid or no lid
A covered roaster traps moisture. That's ideal for pot roast, a smaller chicken, ham, or bread baking. For a crisp-skinned turkey, most cooks roast uncovered and tent loosely with foil if the breast browns too fast. If you're shopping for the best roasting pan with lid for small birds, the Granite Ware oval is our pick; for a big turkey, an uncovered pan with a rack is the usual move.
Stovetop gravy and induction
If gravy from the drippings is the whole point, choose a pan that can go on the burners. Clad stainless pans on induction-compatible picks (both Cuisinarts) can straddle two burners for deglazing, and the HexClad listing says any cooktop, including induction. The Cooks Standard works on gas, electric, glass and ceramic but not induction. For nonstick and enamel pans, follow each maker's directions. When stovetop use isn't stated, pour the drippings into a saucepan and make gravy there.
Oven-safe temperature, dishwasher claims and warranty
Most turkey roasting happens well under 450°F, so every pick here covers a standard roast. Higher limits matter more for broiling or high-heat finishes. When sources disagree (as with HexClad), follow the care instructions in the box. Many listings say "dishwasher safe" but recommend hand washing to protect the finish or coating, and that advice is worth taking. Warranties range from 1 year (Cooks Standard) to lifetime (the Cuisinarts and HexClad, with conditions), and the Granite Ware listing doesn't state one.
How to Roast a Turkey in Your New Pan Without Stress
The week before
Measure your oven's interior width and the pan's overall length, handles included. Leave a couple of inches of clearance on each side.
Check that the pan fits the bird. You want an inch or two of space around the turkey, and the bird's weight should fall within the pan's stated capacity or, if there isn't one, the rough size rule.
Thaw a frozen turkey in the refrigerator. USDA/FoodSafety.gov guidance is about 24 hours for every 4 to 5 pounds, so a 16-pound bird needs roughly three to four days. Count backward from Thursday and start early.
Wash the new pan and rack before first use, following the maker's instructions.
Roasting day
Set the rack in the pan. Scatter onions, carrots, celery and herbs underneath for flavor and better drippings.
Set the oven no lower than 325°F, per USDA/FoodSafety.gov.
Roast uncovered. If the breast browns too quickly, tent it loosely with foil.
Start checking temperature well before you expect it to be done. Use a meat thermometer to confirm 165°F in the thickest part of the breast, the innermost part of the thigh and the innermost part of the wing. If you cooked stuffing inside the bird, it must also reach 165°F.
Lift the turkey out using the rack handles and sturdy mitts, ideally with a second set of hands for big birds. Let it rest before carving, then move it to a large cutting board with room to catch the juices.
Making gravy and cleaning up
Deglaze on the stovetop only if the maker says your pan is stovetop-safe. Otherwise, pour the drippings into a saucepan and make gravy there.
For stainless, soak the pan or simmer a little water in it to loosen stuck-on bits.
For nonstick, skip abrasive pads and steel wool and use a soft sponge.
Even with "dishwasher safe" pans, hand washing usually keeps the finish looking better longer.
Roasting Pan FAQ
What size roasting pan do I need for a 20 lb turkey?
By the general rule cooking guides share, look for an 18-inch-class pan for birds up to about 20 pounds, with an inch or two of space around the bird. Among these picks, Circulon's product page says its roaster holds up to a 24-pound turkey, while the Cuisinart MultiClad Pro listing tops out at 18 pounds. Measure your oven too, since bigger pans need more clearance.
Do I need a roasting pan for turkey?
For a turkey over about 14 pounds, a real roasting pan is the safest, easiest option. It's sturdy, deep enough for drippings and easier to lift than a disposable pan. If you're wondering "do I need a roasting pan" for smaller jobs, a sheet pan, baking dish or Dutch oven can handle a chicken or small roast. For a big bird, though, a proper roaster is worth it.
Do I need a rack in my roasting pan?
A rack isn't mandatory, but it helps. It lifts the bird so the bottom browns, lets air circulate and gives you handles to lift the turkey out. No rack? Set the bird on thick-cut onions, carrots and celery instead.
Is a stainless steel or nonstick roasting pan better?
It depends on your priorities. Stainless has no coating to wear out, and stovetop-safe versions let you make gravy right in the pan, but it's heavier and needs soaking to clean. Nonstick is lighter and easier to clean, though the picks here max out at 450°F and generally aren't meant for high-heat stovetop gravy.
What is the best roasting pan with a lid?
For small birds, roasts and bread, the Granite Ware 13" Oval Roaster is our covered pick. Its listing says it fits up to a 7-pound bird or roast. For a turkey, most cooks roast uncovered for crisp skin and tent with foil as needed, so a lid isn't essential for Thanksgiving.
Is a roasting pan the same as a Dutch oven?
No. A roasting pan is wide and fairly low with an open top, which helps browning and airflow around a large bird. A Dutch oven is deep, heavy and lidded, which makes it great for braises and small roasts but too small and steamy for most turkeys.
Can I use a roasting pan for chicken and vegetables?
Absolutely, and that's how a roasting pan earns its keep the rest of the year. Use the rack for a whole chicken and scatter vegetables around or underneath it. For vegetables alone, a shallower pan like the Farberware or Chicago Metallic helps them brown rather than steam.
Roasting pan vs. baking dish: what's the difference?
Roasting pans are usually larger, sturdier and often come with a rack and big handles for heavy loads. Baking dishes are typically smaller glass or ceramic pieces made for casseroles, lasagna and gratins. A baking dish can roast a small chicken, but it's not built for a big turkey or for stovetop gravy.
The Bottom Line
If you want one pan that does it all, the Cuisinart MultiClad Pro is the best roasting pan for turkey hosts who want stovetop gravy and years of use. Just buy soon, since Cuisinart lists it as discontinued. For stainless on a gentler budget, the Chef's Classic is the move if it fits your oven. Hosting a big crowd? The Circulon's stated 24-pound capacity and light weight stand out. Smaller gatherings and V-rack fans should look at the Cooks Standard, and the HexClad is the splurge for nonstick-style release plus induction gravy. For everyday chicken and vegetables, the Farberware and Chicago Metallic make roasting easy, and the Granite Ware oval is your covered workhorse for small birds and bread.
Whichever you pick, measure your oven, check the pan against your bird, and give yourself a sturdy pan you trust to lift. Here's to a Thanksgiving without buckling foil, a pan full of gravy-ready drippings, and plenty of cozy Sunday roasts long after the leftovers are gone.
By Kiyomi Dyme
Keep reading.

Best Cast Iron Skillet (2026): 8 Picks for Searing, Cornbread and Easy Care
Scratched nonstick pans and holiday cooking ahead? These 8 cast iron skillets cover classic, lightweight, enameled, 2-in-1 and gift sets, plus what size you need, how heavy is too heavy, glass-top tips and easy cleaning and seasoning.
Read Guide
Best Cutting Board (2026): 8 Picks for Raw Meat, Knives and Holiday Prep
Warped, smelly board and Thanksgiving coming? These 8 cutting boards cover composite, plastic, bamboo, maple, teak and walnut, plus a plain-English wood vs plastic guide, raw-meat safety and care tips.
Read Guide
Best Food Processor (2026): 8 Picks for Holiday Prep, Chopping and Pie Crust
Chopping onions for stuffing, shredding cheese for casseroles, pulsing pie crust: these 8 food processors cover big-batch 14-cup models, mid-size picks for small kitchens, a blender combo and easy mini choppers.
Read Guide